Ny med is a medical documentary series which premiered on abc on july 10, 2012. The ny med show included a segment about mark chanko, who was brought into the emergency room at new yorkpresbyterian hospital in april 2011 after he was hit by a truck while crossing a street. Chankos son kenneth complained to hhs about hipaa violations by the hospital after his mother, marks widow recognized her dying husband while watching an. But her feelings about the medical reality programs changed drastically after her husband was featured on ny med. A chief privacy officers take on the chanko case bill. Top ny court revives suit against hospital that let tv.
Mark chankos family sued newyork presbyterian hospital and. More specifically, he details how the death of one mr. Ny meds aired korean war veteran mark chankos death. In 2012, anita chanko was watching an episode of abcs ny med when she saw her late husband mark undergoing treatment in attempts to save him. While his face was blurred, chankos widow was able to identify him when she watched the episode. The fastpaced series toggles between the orderly operating rooms of manhattans new yorkpresbyterian hospital, where renowned surgeons perform feats of medical brilliance, and the hectic trauma wards of newarks university hospital where skilled doctors struggle to treat lifethreatening. It just sent me straight back to square one, she said. The article focuses on an episode in which doctors tried unsuccessfully to save mark chanko, who. She clicked on an episode of ny med, a hospital reality show, and recognized the surgeon who treated my father. Nyp weill cornell staff treating mark chanko, a yorkville, new york.
After that, it could go back to judge mendez, who would then rule on what the defendants must hand over to the chankos. But for relatives of mark chanko, the familys private loss became very public in an unexpected way. On monday, a court ruled that the family of mark chanko, a former resident of stuyvesant town whose death in 2011 after being hit by a truck was filmed for the show ny med, couldnt have unlimited access to the footage. No one in the chanko family had given ny med permission to film mr. Although chankos face was blurred, his widow was able to clearly identify him. Chankos husband, mark chanko, was hit by a truck in 2012 and died shortly after arriving at new yorkpresbyterian hospital. Ny med broadcasts mans death without family consent. On april 28th, 2011, mark chanko was hit by a sanitation truck while. Mark is a korean war veteran who died in april 2011 after being hit by a garbage truck while crossing the street near his house.
Cn the widow of a man whose death was televised on abcs ny med can sue the hospital for breach of physicianpatient confidentiality, new yorks highest court ruled. His face was blurred and his voice altered but chanko s widow, anita, recognized him immediately when watching ny med at home. The new york times reports that ny med is a popular reallife medical series that takes place at new yorks presbyterian hospital. Chanko family to appeal case against ny med and hospital. Mark chanko was filmed at ny presbyterian hospital without the familys consent, and then nationally aired on abcs ny med over a year later. Ny med, season 1, episode 7 minus the mark chanko segment. Sebastian schubl was the hospitals chief surgical resident and was responsible for chankos treatment. On came the prior nights episode of ny med, the popular reallife medical series set at newyork presbyterian hospital. After ny meds premier on abc in july 2012, critics praised the show, citing its hardhitting approach interspersed with moments of warmth and even comedy.
The ensemble cast of ny med is believable, portrayed as hardworking but human as they deal with patients and with the daily problems of living and working in a big city hospital. Widow cannot sue abc over husbands televised death. Abc cannot be sued for airing mans death on ny med. Sixteen months later, decedents widow, plaintiff anita chanko, watched an episode of ny med on her television at home. For the chankos, the episode of ny med added a coda of anger to more than a year of grief. He had been hit by a vehicle but was alert and responding to questions. His death was later shown on an episode of abcs ny med, without his familys. The episode featured a blurredout video of mark chanko, an 83yearold car accident victim, being treated in the ed at new york presbyterian hospitalweill cornell medical center. Abc film crews leave hospitals on the hook for hipaa fines rbs. One episode of ny med depicted the case of an elderly man, mark chanko, who arrived at newyorkpresbyterian hospital after he was hit by a. A separate lawsuit filed by the family is set to be heard in the court of appeals.
Anita chanko was familiar with the program, but had no idea that the film crew had actually filmed, and planned to air, her husbands death. Chanko, deceased died while being treated by said hospital and physicians and his final words, treatment and death were recorded by defendant american broadcasting companies inc. One episode of ny med depicted the case of an elderly man, mark chanko, who arrived at newyork presbyterian hospital after he was hit by a garbage truck. When a patients death is broadcast without permission. That is the same date that a manhattan man named mark chanko was. On january 2, propublica and the new york times copublished when a patients death is broadcast without permission, a powerful article that explored legal and ethical questions posed by abcs ny med and similar tv documentaries about actual medical dramas taking place in hospitals.
The case involving ny med and mark chanko has raised many questions about hospital ethics and patients right to privacy. After watching the episode of ny med, kenneth chanko, marks son, complained to. Their daughter, pamela chanko, 46, said seeing the specifics of her fathers injuries and his death on tv sent her spiraling back into clinical depression. Mark chanko s family sued newyork presbyterian hospital and one of its doctors for allowing a tv crew to film. However, the mans familywho happened to be watching the episode when it airedhad never given the show or the hospital permission to film or broadcast the. While his face was blurred, chanko s widow was able to identify him when she watched the episode. The family had no clue until the following year, when anita chanko, mark chankos widow, saw an episode of ny med and recognized her husbands voice as he lay dying, asking about his wife. Chankos husband, mark chanko, was hit by a truck in 2012 and died. Such moments indeed, all of the intimate details of a persons health are supposed to be shared only with a patient and whoever they designate, under a federal law known as hipaa. On monday, a court ruled that the family of mark chanko, a former resident of. The family of mark chanko is currently working to appeal a case against ny med, abc, newyork presbyterian hospital and dr. After watching the episode of ny med, kenneth chanko, marks son, complained to the hospital and the network, as well as to state and. The episode showed chanko s final moments as he died from his injuries.
Anita chanko, 73, claims that she tuned in to the awardwinning hospital reality show, ny med, a year later and was shocked to hear the voice of her beloved husband and the doctors who. Daughter whos father died on ny med calls for new laws about. When a tv show broadcasts a patients death without permission. Anita chankos husband, mark, was hit by a sanitation truck in manhattan. His death was later shown on an episode of abcs ny med, without. This summer the network aired two new medical reality shows made by the same producers.
New york top court revives suit against hospital that let mans death be filmed. Earlier this month, charles ornstein explored a new york city familys charge that their privacy was violated by a local hospital and a reality television show in propublica. His death was later shown on an episode of abcs ny med, without his familys permission. The episode showed chankos final moments as he died from his injuries. Top ny court revives suit against hospital that let tv crew film mans death without permission. New york times dina litovsky anita chankos husband, mark, was hit by a sanitation truck in manhattan. Abc was filming the show at the new yorkpresbyterian hospital when mark chanko arrived in its emergency room after being hit by a car. Solved mark chanko was brought into the emergency room. Chankos treatment at the hospital or to broadcast the moments leading up to his death. Sebastian schubl who filmed his treatment and death without their consent, the new york times reported. The abc television show ny med filmed mark chankos final moments without the approval of his family. In addition, she saw, and relived, schubl telling the family of his death. Widow shocked to see husbands death on reality tv show daily mail.
Questions arise over hospital reality tv shows center. In 2012, anita chanko was watching an episode of abcs ny med when she saw her late husband mark undergoing treatment in attempts to. Anita chanko is leading a movement to stop reality tv shows from filming. It aired 16 months after chanko s visit to the hospital in 2011. Neither they nor mark chanko had been asked for permission to film, let alone broadcast, chankos death. After watching the episode of ny med, kenneth chanko, marks son, complained to the. The night abcs ny med secretly turned one familys crisis into primetime drama. Chanko died, abc went on to film a second season of ny med. Mark chankos widow reveals horror of watching husbands.
New york hospitals ban filming patients without consent. Chankos widow discovered that the abc crew filmed her husbands treatment at nyp when she saw it broadcast on an episode of ny med in august 2012. New york top court revives suit against hospital that. Chankos death, his widow happened to catch an episode of ny med. Mr chanko, 83, passed away at new yorkpresbyterian hospital in april 2011 after being hit by a truck in manhattan. Anita chanko, widow of 83yearold mark chanko, said that she was shocked when she saw her husbands surgery in a television broadcast of regular episode of. Ny med is back with a riveting tale of high stakes medicine in two different communities. Mark chanko was brought into the emergency room of new york and presbyterian hospital the hospital. Anita chanko has filed a lawsuit against abc and new yorkpresbyterian hospital claiming that her husband mark chankos pictured death was aired on the show ny meds for the entertainment of. The footage of chanko, including his death, and the doctor delivering the sad news to his family who didnt know the doctor was wearing a microphone was used in an episode of an abc show called ny med.
291 230 849 440 1505 948 119 522 1207 1467 97 1575 1152 1197 540 956 399 84 988 911 1249 1537 1005 215 1203 135 717 876 948 947 623 1073 1092 456 1095 795