In a debate within hci research the capability of information processing psychology has been questioned and new theoretical frameworks searched. Culturalhistorical activity theory chat is one of several practice based approaches that provides a robust framework for analyzing professional work practices, incl uding social service provision julkunen, 2011, 20. It traces its origins to the founders of the culturalhistorical school of russian psychology l. Activity theory as a potential framework for humancomputer interaction research. The purpose of the study was to better understand the barriers that keep selfmotivated users of online open education resources from experiencing successful independent learning.
This research afforded the group the opportunity to explore the easeofuse of an activity theory model and a mediating artifacts hierarchy and to experiment with their application. Purpura, in security and loss prevention sixth edition, 20. Technology as an activity system for selfdirected, expanding. Adopting the theory, we describe teachinglearning activities mediated by ict using a three level analysis. Kuutti points to activity theory as a potential answer. Hardman university of cape town, rondebosch, south africa email. Some implications of activity theory and its bridging potential are pursued in the contexts of io theoryconstruction and research methods, and in the substantive problem areas of job design,job. We propose using activity theory as a basis for designing and reporting on research projects that focus on information. Activity theory is neither focused on activities in general nor is it an explicit theory in the sense that it leads to predictive result. Pdf activity theory as a potential framework for human. Activity theory provides a framework of four interactive components from which strategy emerges. The purpose of this article is to argue that activity theory provides an important perspective on the problem of developing practices which are frequently observed to be desirable but remain difficult to develop.
Activity theory as a potential framework for technology research in an unequal terrain j. This paper argues that activity theory provides an appropriate framework for analyzing needs, tasks, and outcomes for designing cles. Toward a third generation of activity theory activity theory provides a powerful framework for analyzing and understanding the social. Activity theory, authentic learning and emerging technologies. Activity theory as a potential framework for humancomputer interaction research readings 09. In other words, activity theory can be considered a theoretical tool for making changes and providing real support for human development through formative experiments and social designs for new activity systems. Towards a transformative higher education pedagogy routledge research in higher education bozalek, vivienne, ngambi, dick, wood, denise, herrington, jan, hardman, joanne, amory, alan on. Barriers to selfmotivated conceptual music learning. Activity theory as a framework for designing constructivist learning environments. This team chose to apply aspects of activity theory in order to identify user needs. The application of activity theory in identifying contradictions in a. A versatile framework for workplace research david dayton during the past decade activity theory has attracted a small but influential group of researchers in two fields that contribute to theory and research in technical communication. This chapter presents an overview of the situation and discusses the potential of activity theory as an alternative framework for hci research and design. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda.
This theory includes the routine activities of both offender and victim. We propose using activity theory as a basis for designing and reporting on research projects that focus on information and communication technology ict as a means to support educational processes. Driving principles of third generation activity theory are a collective, artifactmediated and objectoriented activity system, seen in its network relations to other activity systems, is taken as the prime unit of analysis. Vygotskys mediated action triangle is the first generation of activity theory. Activity theory refers to the psychology developed originally by soviet thinkers starting with lev vygotsky in the 1920s and subsequently articulated further by later soviet psychologists, notably alexei leontyev. South african journal of higher education, 192, p378.
Central concepts of activity theory culturalhistorical activity theory looks at artifacts and people as embedded in dynamic activity systems figure 1. Pdf activity theory as a potential framework for humancomputer. Citeseerx 2 activity theory as a potential framework for. Activity theory as a potential framework for human. Kuutti, k 1996 activity theory as a potential framework for human computer interaction research. Educational technology research and development, 471, 6179. There exists a hierarchical analysis of motivated human action levels of activity analysis. City research online social interactions of computer. Activity theory as a potential framework for technology. Cultural historical activity theory is a new framework aimed at transcending the dichotomies of micro and macro, mental and material, observation and. Activity theory as a potential framework for humancomputer interaction research kari kuutti in recent years the mainstream framework for humancomputer interaction researchinformation processing cognitive psychologyhas come under increasing criticism because of serious problems in applying it in both research and practical design. Activity analysis as a method for information systems development. Culturalhistorical activity theory chat is a theoretical framework which helps to understand and analyse the relationship between the human mind what people think and feel and activity what people do.
An activity theory framework for extreme events usc marshall. The epistemic assumptions of constructive learning are different from those of traditional instruction, so classical methods of needs and task analysis are inappropriate for designing constructivist learning environments cles. At a later time it was advocated for and popularized by alexei leontev. In a debate within the hci research community, the capability of information processing psychology has been questioned and new theoretical frameworks considered. In this article i will discuss the potential that activity theory offers for analysing and rethinking collaborative practice in schools. The perceived barriers to, and facilitators of, effective multiagency working are explored in relation to their potential impact upon the process of engaging service users in change. Given the potential impact schoolbased daily physical activity dpa policies can have on the health outcomes of canadian children, it is surprising that such little research has examined the implementation and studentlevel effectiveness of these policies, and that even less have used theory to understand the barriers and facilitators affecting uptake of this policy by teachers. Presentation on activity theory linkedin slideshare. Introduction to activity theory applied to a work context.
This paper describes the use of activity theory to compare dissimilar cases in a study of adult online music learners. The premise of activity theory is that a collective work activity, with the basic purpose shared by others community, is undertaken by people subjects who are motivated by a purpose or towards the solution of a problem object, which is mediated by tools andor signs artefacts or instruments used in order to achieve the goal. If we think of a designer as the subject of her design work, the initial object would be an idea, order or assignment that triggers the design process. The actions that take place within a mat are analysed from the systemic perspective of sociocultural activity theory at, and supported by examples drawn from.
Appropriating conceptual and pedagogical tools for. In this chapter i ask where each approach seems to be headed and what its emphases and perspectives are. Activity theory as a potential framework for human computer interaction research. Some of the traces of the theory in its inception can also be found in a. During the recent years the mainstream framework for hci research the informationprocessing cognitive psychology has gained more and more criticism. The theory was virtually unknown in the western world until the 1980s but since then it has continued to evolve, mostly through the work of psychologists like yrjo engestrom. A sociocultural framework for language policy and planning. Activity theory as a theoretical framework for health self. Activity theory was used as a framework for the study to account for the systems that link mathematics, learning and the differing social milieus.
An activity theorybased model for serious games analysis. Citeseerx activity theory as a potential framework for. Pdf activity theory as a potential framework for technology. Activity theory shifts attention to the social and cultural factors that mediate development in particular contexts, thus allowing an understanding of how particular preservice and inservice environments guide earlycareer. Activity theory as a potential framework for technology research activity theory as a potential framework for technology research in an unequal terrain in an unequal. This chapter presents an overview of the situation and discusses the potential of activity theory as. Activity theory, situated action models, and distributed cognition are evolving frameworks and will change and grow as each is exercised with empirical study. Activity theory as a framework for humantechnology interaction research. This paper presents an overview of the situation and discusses potentials of activity theory as an alternative framework for hci research and design. Chat has potential utility for analyzing healthcare and social service provider. This article attempts to expand and elaborate activity theory as a theory for studying human computer interaction in south africa. Activity theory as a potential framework for technology research in an unequal terrain. Activity theory is not a black and white set of rules, but a framework for understanding.
The purpose of this discussion is to consider the potential of sociocultural theory as the basis for a broader metatheoretical framework to understand the interrelationship between macro and micro analyses of policy and practice within lpp. Activity theory and humancomputer interaction research. Activity theory as a framework for humantechnology. In this area of studies the theory of gradual development of human intellectual activitycan be used to understand the child ability to manage the interpersonal situation. Activity theory offers a structured framework that considers the game not as an.
Activity theory and the transformation of pedagogic practice. The paper concludes with a consideration of the issues this raises for methodology in the study of lpp. Resources on this site are free to download and reuse according to associated licensing. Activity theory and humancomputer interaction, 1744. People are socioculturally embedded actors not processors or system components. This paper proposes that activity theory provides a useful framework for studying the conceptual development of teachers, particularly englishlanguage arts teachers. Galperins theory of gradual development of human intellectual activity for studying social cognition in children. Activity theory and developmental work research, po box 47, 00014 university of helsinki, finland keywords. The paper is devoted to analysis of the potential of p. Activity theory is a framework or descriptive tool for a system. In order to demonstrate the applicability of activity theory in analysing computermediated social interactions, an exploratory study of online activities in a game community was conducted.
Activity theory uses the whole work activity as the unit of analysis, where the activity is broken into the analytical components of subject, tool and object, where the subject is the person being studied, the object is the intended activity, and the tool is the mediating device. It first sketches ways in which russian activity theory arising out of the work of vygotsky may expand understandings of learning before elaborating the theory in terms of engestroms. Heuristic potential of the gradual development of human. Instead, it is more of a framework for clearly describing and breaking down work and for understanding a. A theoretical analysis of the barriers and facilitators to. Routine activity theory, from cohen and felson 1979, emphasizes that crime occurs when three elements converge.
14 1292 783 1471 1340 1031 566 23 921 1564 463 26 138 1416 893 1570 198 511 167 1067 1479 1050 1492 569 508 864 1499 1089 1008 1247 57 1216